Market risk is the risk of potential losses due to adverse movements in financial market variables. Exposure to market risk is measured by the impact of movements in financial variables such as equity prices, interest rates and property prices.
The various types of market risk which are discussed in this section, are:
interest rate risk (including interest rate volatility risk)
equity risk (including equity volatility risk)
property risk
currency risk
spread risk
concentration risk
Aegon life and Aegon spaarkas use a Partial Internal Model (PIM) to calculate the solvency position. The PIM contains separate modules for (i) interest rate risk, (ii) equity risk, (iii) property risk and (iv) spread risk. For the other risks, the Solvency II standard formula is applied. a.s.r. life, a.s.r. non-life and a.s.r. health use the Solvency II standard formula to calculate the solvency position. The total market risk is therefore the sum of the SF and IM.
The main market risks of a.s.r. are interest rate, equity, property and spread risk. The total market risk amounted to € 4,891 million per year-end 2023 of which € 3,086 million is based on SF and € 1,805 based on IM including Deterministic Adjustment (DA) (2022: € 2,481 million fully based on SF). The increase of € 2,321 million, is mainly the result of the acquisition of Aegon NL combined with higher equity prices.
a.s.r. accepts and manages market risk for the benefit of its customers and other stakeholders. a.s.r.’s risk management and control systems are designed to ensure that these market risks are managed effectively and efficiently, aligned with the risk appetite for the different types of market risks. Market risk reports are submitted to either FRC or RCC at least once a month. In these reports different types of market risks are monitored and tested against the limits according to the financial risk policies.
The value of investment funds at year-end 2023 was € 8,250 million (2022: € 6,823 million). a.s.r. applies the look through approach for investment funds to assess the market risk.
As part of PIM the DA is identified for Aegon life to mitigate volatility caused by the basis risk between (i) the EIOPA VA reference portfolio and (ii) the asset portfolio of Aegon life. The value of the DA at year-end 2023 was € 88 million. Note that the DA is not included in the required capital for market risks when determining the diversification between risks. In the presented figures the DA is included in the market risk.
The diversification effect shows the effect of having a well-diversified investment portfolio.
Solvency II sensitivities
The Solvency II SCR is a Value at Risk-measure. Therefore, Solvency II ratio sensitivities are disclosed as the alternative analysis, instead of IFRS sensitivities, as permitted by IFRS. The sensitivities of the solvency ratio as at 31 December 2023, expressed as the impact on the group solvency ratio (in percentage points) are as presented in the table below. The total impact is split between the impact on the solvency ratio related to movement in the available capital and the required capital. The sensitivities are based on the situation per 31 December 2023 and include Financial Institutions.
Effect on: | Available capital | Required capital | Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scenario (%-point) | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
UFR 3.2% | -4 | -4 | - | - | -4 | -4 |
Interest rate +0.5% (incl. UFR 3.45% for 2023 and 2022) | -2 | -2 | +3 | +1 | - | -1 |
Interest rate -0.5% (incl. UFR 3.45% for 2023 and 2022) | +2 | +1 | -4 | -7 | -2 | -6 |
Interest steepening +10 bps | -1 | -1 | - | - | - | -1 |
Volatility Adjustment -10bp | -10 | -7 | +6 | -3 | -5 | -10 |
Government spread + 50 bps / VA +10 bps (2022: VA: +10 bps) | -5 | -3 | +3 | - | -2 | -3 |
Mortgage spread +50 bps | -10 | -8 | +3 | - | -7 | -7 |
Equity prices -20% | -7 | -11 | +8 | +14 | +1 | +3 |
Property values -10% | -10 | -10 | +2 | +4 | -8 | -6 |
Spread +75bps/ VA +17bps (2022: VA +18bps) | +14 | +10 | -7 | +1 | +7 | +11 |
Inflation +30 bps | -1 | -2 | - | - | -2 | -2 |
Risk | Scenario |
---|---|
Interest rate risk - UFR 3.2% | Measured as the impact of a lower UFR. For the valuation of liabilities, the extrapolation to the UFR of 3.2% after the last liquid point of 20 years remained unchanged. The impact on available capital, required capital and ratio relates to a comparison with a solvency ratio measured at a UFR of 3.45% for 2023 and 2022. |
Interest rate risk (incl. UFR 3.45%) | Measured as the impact of a parallel 0.5% upward and downward movement of the interest rates. For the liabilities, the extrapolation to the UFR (3.45% for both 2023 and 2022) after the last liquid point of 20 years remained unchanged. |
Interest steepening | Measured as the impact of a linear steepening of the interest rate curve between 20Y and 30Y of 1 bps to 10 bps. |
Volatility Adjustment | Measured as the impact of a 10 bps decrease in the Volatility Adjustment. |
Government spread | Measured as the impact of an increase of spread on Government bonds of 50 bps. At the same it is assumed that the Volatility Adjustment will increase by 10 bps (2022: +10 bps). |
Mortgage spread | Measured as the impact of a 50 bps increase of spreads on mortgages. |
Equity risk | Measured as the impact of a 20% downward movement in equity prices. |
Property risk | Measured as the impact of a 10% downward movement in the market value of real estate. |
Spread risk (including impact of spread movement on VA) | Measured as the impact of an increase of spread on loans and corporate bonds of 75 bps. At the same time, it is assumed that the Volatility Adjustment will increase by 17 bps (2022: +18bps) based on reference portfolio. |
Inflation risk | Measured as the impact of a 30 bps parallel increase of the inflation rates (EUSWI-curve). The extrapolation of the UFI remains unchanged. |
7.8.3.1 Interest rate risk
Interest rate risk is the risk that the value of assets or liabilities will change due to fluctuations in interest rates. a.s.r. is exposed to interest rate risk, as both its assets and liabilities are sensitive to movements in long- and short-term interest rates. Insurance products are exposed to interest rate risk. Especially the life insurance products are long-term and therefore particularly sensitive to interest rate risk. The interest rate risk of insurance products depends, besides the term to maturity, on interest rate guarantees and profit-sharing features. Where applicable Knab and Aegon hypotheken prefer to hedge the risk to the extent possible.
Interest rate risk is managed by aligning fixed-income investments to the profile of the liabilities. Among other instruments, swaptions and interest rate swaps are used for hedging the specific interest rate risk arising from interest rate guarantees and profitsharing features in life insurance products. An interest rate risk policy is in place for a.s.r. as well as for the registered insurance companies. Interest rate risk reports are submitted to either FRC or RCC at least once a month. In these reports the interest rate risk is monitored and tested against the limits according to the financial risk policies.
The required capital for interest rate risk is determined by calculating the impact on the available capital due to changes in the yield curve.
The Solvency II SF interest rate risk is the maximum loss of (i) an upward shock and (ii) a downward shock of the yield curve.
The used shocks vary by maturity and the absolute shocks are higher for shorter maturities (descending: 75% to 20% and ascending: -70% to -20%):
The yield curve up shock contains a minimum shock of 100bps;
The yield curve down shock is zero in case the yield curve is negative;
The yield curves of all currencies are shocked simultaneously.
All adjustments (credit spread, volatility adjustment) on the yield curve are considered constant.
The yield curve is extrapolated to the UFR. The yield curve after shock is not extrapolated again to the UFR.
The Solvency II IM for interest rate risks differ from the standard formula results for the following reasons:
The Solvency II PIM interest rate curve shocks are calibrated based on historical market data;
The Solvency II PIM assumes that the UFR does not change in a shock scenario, while the standard formula interest rate shock assumes that the whole curve moves, including the UFR; and
In addition, the Solvency II PIM includes a capital requirement for interest rate volatility risk.
a.s.r. has assessed various scenarios to determine the sensitivity to interest rate risk. The impact on the solvency ratio is calculated by determining the difference in the change in available and required capital and include Financial Institutions1.
Effect on: | Available capital | Required capital | Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scenario (%-point) | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
UFR 3.2% | -4 | -4 | - | - | -4 | -4 |
Interest rate +0,5% (incl. UFR 3.45%) | -2 | -2 | +3 | +1 | - | -1 |
Interest rate -0.5% (incl. UFR 3.45%) | +2 | +1 | -4 | -7 | -2 | -6 |
Interest steepening +10 bps | -1 | -1 | - | - | - | -1 |
Volatility Adjustment -10bp | -10 | -7 | +6 | -3 | -5 | -10 |
The interest rate sensitivity decreased compared to previous year.
7.8.3.2 Equity risk
The equity risk takes into account the risk arising from the sensitivity of the values of assets, liabilities and financial instruments to changes in the level or in the volatility of market prices of equities. Exposure to equity markets exists in both assets and liabilities. Asset exposure exists through direct equity investments. In order to maintain a good understanding of the actual equity risk, a.s.r. applies the look-through approach for investment funds to assess the equity risk. The equity risk of insurance products depends on guarantees and profit-sharing features.
The Solvency II SF equity risk is determined by calculating the impact on the available capital due to an immediate drop in equity prices.
Equities listed in regulated markets in countries in the EEA or OECD are shocked by 39% together with the symmetric adjustment (type I).
Equities in countries that are not members of the EEA or OECD, unlisted equities, alternative investments, or investment funds in which the look-through principle is not possible, are shocked by 49% together with the symmetric adjustment (type II).
Investments of a strategic nature are shocked by 22%.
The equity capital of the renewable investments qualifying as an infrastructure investment (e.g. wind farm Wieringermeer) is shocked by 30% together with the symmetric adjustment.
The Solvency II IM includes an equity shock, which differs from the standard formula shock:
Equity risk shocks are calibrated based on Aegon life’s own portfolio.
The equity exposures are also shocked for equity volatility risks.
Effect on: | Available capital | Required capital | Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scenario (%-point) | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
Equity prices -20% | -7 | -11 | +8 | +14 | +1 | +3 |
- 1 Sensitivities include Financial Institutions.
Composition of equity portfolio
The total fair value of equities and similar investments at year-end 2023 was € 3,738 million (2022: € 2,604 million). The increase in 2023 was mainly due to the acquisition of Aegon NL. Please note that the total fair value of equities and similar investments referred to in this section does not include "Assets held for index-linked and unit-linked contracts". Although the risks of these assets are primarily for the policyholders, guarantees within certain products may transfer some of the risk to a.s.r.
The equities are diversified across the Netherlands (including participating interests), other European countries and the United States. A limited part of the portfolio consists of investments in emerging markets and alternatives. A portfolio of options with a value of € 30 million is in place to mitigate the equity risk.
The table below shows the exposure of the equity portfolio to different categories. The total value is including the equities in externally managed funds. The category Other contains the investments of ASR infrastructure Renewables (AIR) in windmill - and solarparks which are in scope of 'Qualifying infrastructure equities other than corporate' (€ 190 million).
Please note that the total exposures to equity referred to in this section does not include "Assets held for index-linked and unit-linked contracts". Although the risks of these assets are primarily for the policyholders, guarantees within certain products may transfer some of the risk to a.s.r.
7.8.3.3 Property risk
The property risk takes into account the risk arising from the sensitivity of the values of assets, liabilities and financial instruments to changes in the level or in the volatility of market prices of real estate. The property risk depends on the total exposure to real estate. In order to maintain a good understanding of the actual property risk, a.s.r. applies the look through approach for investment funds and participations which activities are primarily real estate investments.
The Solvency II SF property risk is determined by calculating the impact on the available capital due to an immediate drop in property prices by 25%. Both assets and liabilities are taken into account. The product Agrarische Impact Erfpacht (AIE) has effectively a lower charge due to the underlying risk mitigating characteristics of this product.
The Solvency II IM for property risk includes an IM property shock, which differs from the standard formula shock.
The sensitivity of the solvency ratio to changes in property value is monitored on a monthly basis. Sensitivity of regulatory solvency (Solvency II) to changes in property prices is shown in the following table.
Effect on: | Available capital | Required capital | Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scenario (%-point) | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
Property values -10% | -10 | -10 | +2 | +4 | -8 | -6 |
- 1 Sensitivities include Financial Institutions.
Composition of property portfolio
The property risk depends on the total exposure to property, which includes both property investments and property held for own use. The fair value of property was € 9,193 million at year-end 2023 (2022: € 5,001 million). The increase in 2023 (approximately € 4,192 million) was a result of the acquisition of Aegon NL (approximately € 4,272 million), a decrease of property values (approximately € -149 million), improved lookthrough data of property funds (approximately € 56 million) and transactions (approximately € 12 million).
Please note that the total exposures to property referred to in this section does not include "Assets held for index-linked and unit-linked contracts". Although the risks of these assets are primarily for the policyholders, guarantees within certain products may transfer some of the risk to a.s.r.
7.8.3.4 Currency risk
Currency risk measures the impact of losses related to changes in currency exchange rates. The table below provides an overview of the currencies with the largest exposures. a.s.r. has currency risk to insurance products in American dollars (USD), Australian dollars (AUD), South African Rands (ZAR) and Canadian dollars (CAD).
A currency risk policy is in place for a.s.r. as well as for the registered insurance companies. For different investment categories a.s.r. has defined a target hedge ratio. Currency risk reports are submitted to either FRC or RCC at least once a month. In these reports the currency risk is monitored and tested against the limits according to the financial risk policies.
The required capital for currency risk is determined by calculating the impact on the available capital due to a change in exchange rates. Both assets and liabilities are taken into account and a look-through approach is applied for investment funds. For each currency the maximum loss due to an upward and a downward shock of 25% is determined except for a small number of currencies where lower shocks are applied (a.o. Danish crown).
| 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
---|---|---|
SCR currency risk - required capital | 226 | 135 |
In 2023 the Solvency II SF currency risk has increased with € 90 million. The main reason for this increase is the acquisition of Aegon NL (€ 50 million). The remaining increase of € 40 million can be explained by an increase in equity prices and a lower currency hedge ratio for non-euro equities. The increase is partly offset by an increase in the currency hedge ratio for USD bonds.
Specification currencies with largest exposure
The total foreign exchange exposure at year-end 2023 was € 772 million (2022: € 573 million). The increase in 2023 (approximately € 200 million) was the result of the acquisition of Aegon NL ( € -6 million), an increase in equity prices and a lower currency hedge ratio for non-euro equities. Please note that the total foreign exchange exposure referred to in this section does not include "Assets held for index-linked and unit-linked contracts". Although the currency risk of these assets are primarily for the policyholders, guarantees within certain products may transfer some of the risk to a.s.r.
7.8.3.5 Spread risk
Spread risk arises from the sensitivity of the value of assets and liabilities to changes in the level of credit spreads on the relevant risk-free interest rates. a.s.r. has a policy of maintaining a well-diversified high-quality investment grade portfolio while avoiding large risk concentrations. Going forward, the volatility in spreads will continue to have possible short-term effects on the market value of the fixed income portfolio. In the long run, the credit spreads are expected to be realised and contribute to the growth of the own funds. Exposure to spread risk exists in both assets and liabilities. Asset exposure exists mainly through fixed income investments and mortgages. In order to maintain a good understanding of the actual spread risk, a.s.r. applies the look-through approach for investment funds. The spread risk of insurance products depends on guarantees and profit-sharing features.
The Solvency II SF spread risk is equal to the sum of the capital requirements for bonds, structured products and credit derivatives. Bonds and loans guaranteed by governments or international organisations could be in scope of counterparty default risk instead of spread risk. The capital requirement depends on (i) the market value, (ii) the modified duration and (iii) the credit quality category.
The Solvency II PIM for spread risk includes an IM spread shock which differs from the standard formula:
Spread shocks are calibrated on the basis of Aegon life’s fixed income portfolio.
In contrast to the standard formula, government bonds are shocked with a factor larger than zero.
Mortgages are in scope of the spread risk module, while under the standard formula mortgages are in scope of counterparty default risk. Hence, as a result, the spread risk inherent in a.s.r.'s mortgage portfolio is partly included in this section and partly under counterparty default risk. In particular, the mortgage portfolios of Aegon life and Aegon spaarkas are included in this section since these entities use the Partial Internal Model (PIM), while the mortgage portfolios of a.s.r. life, a.s.r. non-life and a.s.r. health are included under counterparty default risk since these entities apply the Solvency II Standard Formula (SF).
Furthermore, the Solvency II PIM makes use of a dynamic volatility adjustment approach within Aegon life, while the standard formula does not. The Dynamic Volatility Adjustment methodology follows an asset-only approach, ensuring spread widening is the biting scenario.
The performance of the fixed income portfolio is assessed under a broad range of credit scenarios and the model determines which part of the (short-term) losses experienced by the assets are recouped.
The sensitivity to spread risk is measured as the impact of an increase of spread on loans and corporate bonds of 75 bps. The VA is based on a reference portfolio. An increase of 75 bps of the spreads on loans and corporate bonds within the reference portfolio leads to an increase of the VA with 17 bps in 2023 (2022: 18 bps). The credit spread sensitivity decreased from +11 to +7.
Effect on: | Available capital | Required capital | Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scenario (%-point) | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 | 31 December 2023 | 31 December 2022 |
Spread +75bps/ VA +17bps (2022: VA +18bps) | +14 | +10 | -7 | +1 | +7 | +11 |
- 1 Sensitivities include Financial Institutions.
Composition of fixed income portfolio
Spread risk is managed on a portfolio basis within limits and risk budgets established by the relevant risk committees. Where relevant, credit ratings provided by the external rating agencies are used to determine risk budgets and monitor limits. A limited number of fixed-income investments do not have an external rating. These investments are generally assigned an internal rating. Internal ratings are based on methodologies and rating classifications similar to those used by external agencies.
The following tables provide a detailed breakdown of the fixed-income exposure by (i) rating class and (ii) sector. Assets in scope of spread risk are, by definition, not in scope of counterparty default risk. The total exposure of assets in scope of spread risk is € 51,911 million (2022: € 20,653 million). The increase in 2023 (€ 31,258 million) was almost entirely the result of the acquisition of Aegon NL.
The portfolio decomposition changed due to the acquisition of Aegon NL. Among others, the mortgage portfolios of Aegon life and Aegon spaarkas are included as per 31 December 2023. In particular, this led to a significant increase of the non-rated fixed income percentage from 11% to 33%.
Please note that the total fixed-income exposure referred to in this section does not include "Assets held for index-linked and unit-linked contracts". Although the risks of these assets are primarily for the policyholders, guarantees within certain products may transfer some of the risk to a.s.r.
7.8.3.6 Market risk concentrations
Concentrations of market risk constitute an additional risk to an insurer. Concentration risk is the concentration of exposures to the same counterparty. Other possible concentrations (region, country, etc.) are not in scope. The capital requirement for concentration risk is determined in three steps:
determine the exposure above threshold. The threshold depends on the credit quality of the counterparty;
calculation of the capital requirement for each counterparty, based on a specified factor depending on the credit quality;
aggregation of individual capital requirements for the various counterparties.
According to the spread risk module, bonds and loans guaranteed by a certain government or international organisation are not in scope of concentration risk. Bank deposits can be excluded from concentration risk if they fulfil certain conditions.
a.s.r. continuously monitors exposures in order to avoid concentrations in a single obligor outside of the risk appetite and has an overall limit on the total level of the required capital for market risk concentrations. The calculation of the market risk concentrations applies to the total investment portfolio, where, in line with Solvency II, government bonds are not included.
The required capital for market risk concentrations is nil as per year-end 2023 (2022: nil).
- 1As of 2023 a.s.r. reports a Solvency II ratio including Financial Institutions. The 2022 figures have been restated accordingly.